S8 E5 - An updated answer to the question, "Should I go Rogue?"

Podcast



Subscribe to the Podcast

Should I Go Rogue?

Welcome to this episode of the Structured Literacy Podcast, recorded here on the lands of the Palawa people in Tasmania. I'm Jocelyn and I am delighted that you are here. Almost four years ago, in the first season of the Structured Literacy Podcast, I recorded an episode titled Should I Go Rogue? This episode focused on what to do when you are a teacher who is on the bus of structured literacy, but you're being asked to use balanced literacy practices in your classroom. The conclusion shared in that episode was that you should, as best you can, find a win-win between the school's guidelines and what you know as a teacher to be most effective, especially for students who struggle.

Revisiting the Question

It's November 2026 at the time of recording this episode, and I feel compelled to revisit this question once again. Not because practices haven't changed in the past four years, but because there is a whole new set of challenges faced by teachers who are doing their best to get great outcomes for students while being asked to do some things that don't really make sense. So in this episode, I'm dusting off that question, should I go rogue? and looking at it through a new lens. Now, for any leaders listening, please know that I'm not about to launch into an irresponsible rant about teachers who should just go their own way and not worry about the school or system requirements.

The short answer to the question is the same as it was in 2023: you work for a system and that system has requirements. There's a professional obligation to honour the responsibilities that come with employment. But the answer doesn't stop there because things are always more complicated than it feels like they should be.

Let's begin by unpacking some of the points of friction teachers are currently encountering. Some of these relate to previous episodes of this podcast, and if they do, we'll link back to them in the show notes.

"Teach Whole Class Always"

So issue number one is the advice, or the requirement, to teach whole class always. This is a huge one. When I run a course or I just speak with teachers, they all tell me that they know exactly which students are getting nothing out of their low variance phonics lessons because they're either so far behind that the student can't properly access the content or they already know everything that's about to be taught. Somewhere along the journey of the past four years, the message of, "create efficiency by not teaching in small groups what could be taught to a large group" has morphed into, "only teach whole class." Now, this is not helped by phonics programs that use a model of whole class teaching for about 40 minutes, regardless of where the students are up to, followed by small group rotations. It's also not helped when consultants and other people spread the message that this issue is settled science, because it is not. This system not only leaves some students out of the learning process, but it also encourages the colossal waste of instructional time we were trying to get away from in ditching small group rotations in the first place. This is also related to what I am comfortable calling a misunderstanding. That is, "be ambitious for all students in the name of equity," somehow being translated into, "it's more equitable to teach grade appropriate content, regardless of where the students are up to."

Now, my version of being ambitious is expecting that all students will make appropriate learning growth in a year at school. I quite like the old 12 months of learning for 12 months at school. It's neat and tidy and keeps us focused on what counts, which is student learning. When it comes to the equity part, let's be really clear. When I say that we might not teach whole class, I'm talking about concepts and skills that must be built to mastery before adding in the next part of the sequence, namely phonics and early reading and spelling, and the foundations of number. It doesn't make sense to ask a student to deal with numbers to a thousand when they can't reliably count to a hundred, use place value to a hundred to solve addition and subtraction problems, or name the number before and after a given digit.

So everything other than these things is pitched at grade level, with adjustments and stretch provided as needed. That's common sense, and it's a great principle to work with. This is also not just my opinion. This is a message being echoed by other people in the space, like Stephanie Stoller, by Nancy Young, and by other people who I've spoken with who are very well regarded for their knowledge and experience.

Needing a Different Starting Point

Now, what we have now, and what is hurting teachers' hearts, is that teachers can see the students in front of them who need a different starting point. They're seeing those students slumped in their seats because they know they can't be successful in the lessons. Teachers can feel the engagement disappearing in their more capable and advanced students because there's no challenge in what's being presented for them to do. Teachers know that the "whole class always" approach doesn't work. But so many are being told to just follow what has, unbelievably to me, become conventional wisdom, even when the data is showing that it's simply not working for a whole heap of students.

Provides "Exposure"

One of the justifications for whole class teaching at so-called grade level is that this provides exposure for students. Exposure as a teaching tool is one of the biggest myths out there. When we are exposed to stimuli, it sits in our sensory memory for the briefest of moments and then disappears. What is needed for learning is active cognitive engagement with repetition. We need to optimise intrinsic load, maximise every instructional minute, and ensure the right number and the right kind of reps to make the learning stick.

Now, how do we know that exposure doesn't work? Because schools all around the country are exposing students to a whole lot of content and none of it is sticking in a way that is meaningful and long-lasting. Please don't take my word for it. Have a look at your own students and your own end-of-year data. What is it showing?

Flexible Grouping Based on Need

The alternative here is to group students based on their point of need across classrooms and have the whole team share the responsibility for targeted instruction in flexible groups. This is not streaming. Streaming is declaring that this child goes in the bottom group and this child goes in the top group and then they are treated differently. When I talk about flexible grouping, I'm talking about the groups are changed regularly in response to what we're seeing in the data. And flexible grouping is one of the commonalities that we are seeing in every school we work with who is smashing it in their data. The more targeted you are when building the foundations of literacy and numeracy, the better the learning sticks and the better the outcomes are. Now, we'll link to an episode of this podcast here where I share exactly what I found when I went searching for research about grouping for phonics. And I don't want you to take my word for it, ever. I want you to know it for yourself. So have a listen to what I'm sharing, have a look at your data and ask yourself: is our current system of instruction getting the job done?

Research-Informed

Now, a note on research informed practice. I've shared this before, but you might be a new listener to the podcast or maybe can use a bit of a refresher. A really practical and helpful way to think about it is like this, which is borrowed from social work here in Australia. We begin with the quantitative, replicated, reliable, peer-reviewed research that helps us understand what is most likely to get a good outcome for students. Then, when you have experience of strong learning, when you're seeing desirable lasting changes in student outcomes, you can bring professional judgement about the how of instruction to the table. If you don't have that experience yet, then you can reach out to others who do. Finally, cross-reference that with the experience of the end user (in this case, it's the students). What are you seeing in the data as well as in student engagement and well-being? If students are crying and that 12 months of learning for 12 months of school is only showing up for some, something is off. Conversely, if you have strong data across the board, behavioural data that shows fewer negative incidents at that time every day, and students are telling you that they feel like they're learning, then you're onto something. That's the experience of one of our schools who has taken a targeted, data-informed approach to building word-level knowledge in the upper primary years. Their spelling progress monitoring data is showing real and important growth. Their behaviour data is showing fewer instances of negative student behaviours. And the teachers are seeing that the students are much more engaged. Oh, and teacher workload is also significantly reduced. So that kind of win-win-win should be far more common than it is. In fact, I know that it can be because we're seeing it in front of us.

Expectations of a Test

The other point of friction that I'd like to unpack in this episode is where decisions for instruction are being made at the school level to be able to conform to the expectations of a test, even when it means compromising overall learning of students. Now, this one sits at a point that really does have leaders between a rock and a hard place, especially when the school is going to be judged externally based on the results of the test. This reality, compliance and external judgement-focused management by systems, can cause considerable stress for leaders and teachers alike. It's also true that teachers are being put in a sticky spot and have to navigate the school level direction as well as their own personal sense of responsibility to their students. Now, this one shows up in a few ways. It can look like teaching concepts before students are ready because they appear on a test. For example, spending time teaching letter names to students who don't have solid phoneme-grapheme correspondences yet because DIBELS has a letter naming subtest. Now, letter names are useful, we are not denying children learning about letter names. But when I'm not blending yet, when I don't have phoneme-grapheme correspondences under my belt, letter names are not going to help me. And I've never met a student whose reading progress was hampered by not knowing all the letter names yet. Whereas I've met loads of students who have been impacted by not having strong and automatic phoneme-grapheme correspondences.

Mandated Assessments

Another way we see this at play is when there are assessments that are mandated by a system and aligned to a particular scope and sequence. This can be tricky because the pressure to use that scope and sequence is definitely strong. Now, not all sequences are created equal, and there are some general principles that make a sequence more or less inclusive and cognitive load friendly, such as making sure that we are explicitly and properly teaching concepts before we ask students to use them, putting graphemes that are more common for students in the early years earlier on in the sequence, rather than going purely by the frequency that we see in text everywhere, and separating out graphemes that look and sound the same to support our students with dyslexia and other learning challenges, particularly when it comes to the Complex Code.

Choosing a scope and sequence usually comes with instructional implications. And again, not all lesson structures are created equal. We often hear from our Resource Room members that they really like our lesson style because it leads to stronger student learning, but they have to use their school scope and sequence. For leaders listening to this, I know that it's hard, but please prioritise strong teacher and student outcomes overall rather than doing something that isn't best for student outcomes because we're scared of an assessment. I promise you, focusing on the highest quality instruction possible is going to serve your students much better than doing something that's messy and makes a muddle in their brain, because the schema hasn't been well built, the skills haven't been learned to automaticity, and everything is just a mess. I've already spoken about exposure in this episode, and we have a whole episode on it in this podcast: season six, episode 21, Why Exposure is a Poor Substitute for Learning.

Justifying It

Now, as discussed today, exposure is used to justify whole-class teaching. It's also used as a justification for teaching to the test. Just chucking in some correspondences and high-frequency words into the daily review so that we can give students so-called exposure to the upcoming content doesn't get the job done. At best, this is a waste of precious time that could be spent on things that will make a difference, like extra word work or extra retrieval of the content that's actually been taught properly. At worst, we are placing students in an impossible situation where we are expecting them to respond speedily to something that they have never been taught. And I can guarantee you that, in their minds, it is not the instruction that is at fault, it is them. So if we want higher levels of engagement from our students, lower levels of negative behavioural instances in our classrooms, we need to set them up for success. And we also need to remember that throwing extra things into a daily review means that we aren't actually doing review. We're throwing things at kids that we hope will stick.

So, what can we do when faced with these points of friction? How can we meet our professional obligations while doing what we know because our data and our experience tell us it's best for students? Here are five actions that enable you to get closer to the goal you're seeking.

Action One: A List

Number one, make a big list of all the things you can control. You can control what your classroom assistant colleague focuses on with students in your classroom. You can control what goes home for additional reps. Inside the Resource Room, we now have practice packs focused on just one grapheme at a time. One day of introduction and four days of practice designed to be managed in about 10 minutes. Participants in our Reading Success in Tier 2 and 3 Teach Aong course this year also had access to a great online assessment and planning tool that helps you pinpoint exactly what your students need and then hyperlinks you through to the resources you need to use. Now that tool will be available to all Resource Room members in the new year at no additional cost. Practice packs are right now, in November, available for the Complex Code, and the Basic Code will be published in the next couple of weeks.

Depending on your school's requirements, you may be able to control whether your biggest strugglers participate in the whole class lesson you are running or whether they can work in a small group inside your classroom right at that point of need. You may be able to propose that the biggest strugglers from each class in your year level or cohort get to be flexibly grouped and working with a learning support teacher during the core phonics time. This is going to get you a much better outcome, assuming that those students are roughly at the same point of need than that learning support teacher taking them for 10 minutes each twice a week. This is often seen as an acceptable adjustment and will get over the line when every child being flexibly grouped won't be allowed by leadership.

Focusing on the controllables also keeps your blood pressure under control. There's nothing more stressful than feeling like your hands are tied when you have the exact solution that you know will help. Trust me, I get it. It's a situation that I'm encountering more and more on a regular basis. The ancient tradition of Stoicism, with a big S, suggests feeling your feelings. Don't hide them or push them down. Feel all the feels and then focus on what you can control. Trying to change something that is entirely out of your hands is folly and results in us being caught in a helplessness vortex that can be difficult to break free from.

Action Two: Data Conversations

The second thing you can do is to have data conversations with your colleagues and leadership using objective, non-biased language. Student data, including DIBELS, the phonics screening check, your own in-class phonics assessment connected to your phonics program, and student work samples, are all evidence of the impact of the system of instruction you have in your school. It's not about some teachers doing a good job. It's about, is our system of instruction, that is the way we work here, doing what we need it to do.

Of course, any arrangement of instruction will work for at least some students. But what we're looking for is a system of instruction that works for all students. Being able to quantify your viewpoint with statements like, "Our data shows that our system of instruction is working for 60% of our students," is much more likely to get people listening than, "I don't feel good about this, I don't feel like it's working." Data, and the school's own data at that, isn't personal, it can't be seen as a complaint. It is what it is. You have unshakable facts. But how safe you feel making those points and having these discussions is completely up to you.

Action Three: Get Involved

If you want to influence that school level, get involved. If there's a literacy committee, join it. If there's a data team, be part of it. Be in the space where decisions are made.

Action Four: Find the Win-win

As I shared in the original episode about deciding whether or not to go rogue, the goal isn't to ignore your school or your system's requirements. It's to find the win-win in the situation that ensures you are responding professionally, both to the school or system and to your students. So if there's a scope and sequence linked to a central assessment, your school may say that you have to use it. However, you can get better outcomes for students by changing up how the instruction happens. You can make the learning more cognitive load-friendly and responsive to the students in front of you by adjusting the pacing, not moving on until the students are done.

And we're here to help with that too. We already have Basic Code lessons in the Resource Room aligned with both the Victorian scope and sequence and the preferred Queensland scope and sequence, the one that's referred to in your assessment documents. By the time school starts next year, we'll have our lesson resources, including phonics, early morphology, and high frequency words, in the Resource Room aligned to every major scope and sequence. This is in response to the many requests we have had from teachers who can see that our lessons serve students really well, but can't quite figure out how to use them and be true to what their school needs them to do. Now, while I don't love how other sequences are arranged, I absolutely recognise the position that teachers are in and we want to help. I also want to be really clear: we are not pretending to be those other programs, we are not trying to replicate what they have. We are helping you to find a win-win between the instruction that we know works and the responsibilities that you have.

Action Five: Ask Leadership for Clarity

And finally, ask your leadership team for clarity about exactly where the lines are when it comes to your whole school approach. Find out what the non-negotiables are and where teachers have room to respond to the needs of students. I have never met a principal who says, we don't want teachers to adjust to respond to students' needs. In fact, they want more responsiveness. But where things get wobbly is when respond to your students becomes a free-for-all. So make it safer for your principal or leadership team to say yes to what you're looking for. As a leader, it's wonderful to have a teacher or team say, "We've been looking at the data and we see a gap in this. We'd like to do a four-week sprint to see if we can address it. Can we run some ideas by you? And at the end of that sprint, we'll know we've been successful because the data will show X, Y, and Z." Now that is music to a leader's ears.

Where Focus Goes, Energy Flows

I'm going to finish up this episode with the same ending as from the original episode in 2023. I'd like to remind you that where focus goes, energy flows. If you are putting all of your cognitive and emotional energy into things that you cannot control and you cannot change, you are likely missing an opportunity to positively influence and impact student outcomes, particularly for our most vulnerable students. Control the controllables, find the win-wins, and keep the lines of communication open with the decision makers in your school. There's that saying that together everyone achieves more, and it is so very true. Collective efficacy is powerful, reaching that point where we have collective efficacy around structured literacy can and usually does take more time than we would like. But as long as we are moving forward, as long as we are bringing people on the journey, using our data as the feedback on the effectiveness of our system of instruction, then we know that we are going to do great things for kids. I'll see you on the next episode of the Structured Literacy Podcast. Until then, happy teaching.

Show Notes:

S1 E5 - Should I Go Rogue or Follow My School's Approach to Literacy?

S7 E5 - What Does the Research Actually Say About Grouping Students for Phonics?

S6 E21 - Why Exposure is a Poor Substitute for Learning


Looking for the new practice packs for the Complex Code? Want to see the lesson resources for your scope and sequence next year? Join us inside The Resource Room!

0 comments

There are no comments yet. Be the first one to leave a comment!

Leave a comment